A deep sea fishing boat off Playa Avellanas, Guanacaste, Costa Rica
Guanacaste, Costa Rica

Deep sea fishing in Guanacaste, near Tamarindo

Thirty miles off this coast the bottom falls away and the water turns the color of ink. That is where the billfish are. Closer in, within sight of the beach you walked that morning, roosterfish hunt the rocky points. Guanacaste gives you both within a single morning’s drive of Playa Avellanas, and it fishes every month of the year.

A morning offshore

Our own trip, boarding five minutes from the gate — what the run out looks like and what came over the rail.

A deep sea fishing charter off the Guanacaste coast of Costa Rica

What deep sea fishing off Guanacaste actually means

“Deep sea” and “offshore” mean the same thing here: running fifteen to thirty miles out to where the shelf drops and the current lines gather. That is a full day, eight to ten hours including the run, and it is how you reach sailfish, marlin, yellowfin tuna and mahi mahi.

The alternative is inshore — staying within a mile or two of the coast, working the rocky points and river mouths for roosterfish, snapper, grouper and jacks. Four to five hours, far less fuel, far less commitment, and a much better first trip for children or anyone unsure about a long day in open water.

Most groups staying at Johnny’s do one of each across a week: a full offshore day for the people who came to catch a billfish, and a half day inshore for everyone else.

Chartering a fishing boat in Tamarindo, Guanacaste, Costa Rica
Boarding at Playa Avellanas, about five minutes from the gate.
Fishing for mahi mahi offshore in Guanacaste, Costa Rica
Offshore, where the shelf drops and the current lines gather.

The billfish: sailfish and marlin

Sailfish are the fish most people picture when they book a deep sea charter in Costa Rica, and the North Pacific coast is one of the most reliable places on earth to catch one. They average 80 to 120 pounds, they fight on the surface, and they put on the display that makes the photograph — the dorsal fin spread, the whole fish clear of the water. December through April is the strongest run, and on a good day in that window a boat can raise several.

Blue marlin are the heavier prize — 200 to 400 pounds is common and the big ones go well beyond that. They run best May through September, offshore along the same current lines. Black marlin show up less often but they do show, and they are the strongest fish most anglers will ever hook.

All billfish are catch and release in Costa Rican waters. You get the fight, the leader touch, the photograph, and the fish swims away.

The fish you take home: mahi mahi, tuna and wahoo

Mahi mahi — dorado locally — are the fish that make a trip feel generous. They hunt in schools under floating debris, they are spectacular to look at, and they are among the best eating fish in the ocean. They turn up in numbers from May through September, when the rains push debris lines out from the river mouths.

Yellowfin tuna follow the spinner dolphin pods offshore and run from forty pounds into the hundreds. They fight straight down, which is a different and more punishing kind of work than a sailfish. May through September again, overlapping the marlin.

Wahoo are the fastest thing you will hook here — a strike that empties a reel before anyone has touched it. They are less predictable than the rest, more often a bonus than a target.

These are the fish that come back to the property. Whatever lands on the dock, Karla cooks that evening.

A mahi mahi caught deep sea fishing from Johnny's Beach Bungalow, Costa Rica
Mahi mahi. What comes back goes on the grill the same night.

Inshore: roosterfish and the rocky points

The roosterfish — pez gallo — is the signature inshore fish of this coast and one of the reasons serious anglers come to Guanacaste specifically. The seven-spined comb on its back goes up when it hunts, and it hunts in water shallow enough that you watch the whole thing happen. The water straight off Playa Avellanas is among the better roosterfish ground in the country.

They are caught all year, strongest May through September, almost always on live bait worked close to structure. They are a sport fish rather than a food fish and go back in the water.

The same ground holds cubera and red snapper, grouper, jack crevalle and amberjack — all of them good eating, all of them reachable on a half day.

Month by month

  • December – April. Peak sailfish, dry season, flattest water. The classic window, and the busiest.
  • May – September. Blue marlin, yellowfin tuna and mahi mahi at their best, roosterfish at their strongest inshore. Green season, so expect afternoon rain — boats leave at dawn and are usually back before it arrives.
  • October – November. The quietest months on the water and the cheapest time to come. Inshore fishing holds up well.

There is no closed month. The question is only which fish you are prioritizing.

What a boat costs

Budget roughly $100 to $150 per person for a half day. The boats take four to six people and are priced by the boat rather than per head, so the number falls as the group grows: a full boat of six lands at the bottom of that range, a group of four nearer the top. It is one of the few things that gets cheaper when you travel with a crowd.

These are local fishermen, not a charter company with a booking desk and a markup. That is the reason the number is what it is, and it is why the same morning costs noticeably less here than it does booked out of Tamarindo.

Fishing near Tamarindo, without the drive to Tamarindo

Most people searching for fishing in Tamarindo are really searching for this stretch of coast. Tamarindo is the name on the map, so it is where the charter fleet advertises — but the water those boats run to is the same water that sits straight off Playa Avellanas, thirty minutes further south.

Staying at Johnny’s, you skip the part where you get up at four to drive north. You board about five minutes from the gate. Same fishery, same species, same morning light, with half an hour more sleep and a smaller bill at the end of it.

If you are already booked in Tamarindo and want this coast, the drive works perfectly well in reverse. It is just a longer start to the day than it needs to be.

Booking a charter from Johnny’s

You board about five minutes from the gate, at Playa Avellanas. Not Tamarindo, not a thirty-minute drive before sunrise — you are on the water almost as soon as you are awake.

These are local fishermen running boats that take four to six people, and Alberto books directly with the boat captains. No rental car, no arranging it from abroad, no deposit to a company you found online.

Tell us when you book your stay and it is set up before you land. And whatever comes back goes to Karla to cook up. Whether you want grilled fish, a fillet, fish tacos or ceviche, she’ll make it taste fantastic.

From the ocean to the plate

Fifteen seconds, filmed the same day: the mahi mahi that came over the rail that morning, on the table that evening.

No restaurant run, no cooler of fish you have to figure out what to do with. You hand it to Karla and she handles the rest.

Karla cooking a freshly caught mahi mahi at Johnny's Beach Bungalow, Playa Avellanas

Add a fishing day to your stay

Tell us your dates and how many are fishing, and Alberto will set up the boat.

Check availability Ask a question

Booking direct saves you 10% against the Airbnb price.